How financial advisors convert prospects to clients

How to grow a financial advisory practice without buying more leads

Most financial advisors who feel stuck on growth do the same thing. They buy more leads, run more ads, sign up for another lead aggregator, and wait for the numbers to move. And then they watch the same thing happen: a lot of activity, not enough new clients, and no clear explanation for why.

The problem isn't the volume of leads but what happens to the leads.

Estate Guru recently sat down with Derek Notman to find out where the real problem lives. Notman is a CFP, 20-year financial advisor, and founder of Couplr AI, a behavioral matching platform that connects advisors with the right clients through behavior science and AI. His diagnosis is direct: "Most advisors, whether you're a solo advisor or you're part of a larger RIA, you most likely don't have a lead generation problem. You have a lead conversion problem."

Why financial advisory leads are not converting

When growth stalls, most advisors reach for the same solution. Buy more leads, add another list, run more ads. Notman calls this the lead gen trap. "At first glance, if I buy more leads and I buy a thousand names on this list and I close 10 of them, hopefully that'll pay for the list and maybe a little bit more," he said. "But we didn't diagnose the original problem at its core."

The original problem is channel selection. Advisors are spending money in the coldest possible places and wondering why conversion rates stay low. "We have to be careful where we're putting that money," Notman said. "Are we putting it into warmer or colder channels? Because the colder ones are always going to convert a lot less. We've all done the cold lead list thing and it's brutal to call and try to convert all of those."

The more specific problem is that cold channel leads require advisors to compete for the same contact, reach out first without any context, and ask for trust before earning it. "Most advisors didn't sign up to do that part of the job," Notman said. "They just want to sit across the table and help people with their estate planning, their retirement planning, cash flow, insurance, all the things."

"We essentially have a behavior problem when it comes to conversions, not so much a marketing one," he added. Getting in front of the right people through the right channels, and letting trust develop before the first conversation, is what actually moves the number.

Why most financial advisors struggle to win clients

Notman identifies three factors that determine whether a prospect becomes a client: fit, timing, and trust. Surface level, this is a conversation about quality versus quantity in leads. This relationship approach encourages advisors to see that the same the same principles that build meaningful and lasting relationships, things like shared values and showing up when it matters, also applies to how they can work in business. The relationship is the lead.

Advisor-client fit

Fit is whether the advisor and the prospect are actually a good match, not just in terms of what the client needs financially, but in terms of shared interests, shared values, and whether there is a real human connection worth building on. Notman struggled with how to define his ideal client for years until the answer came from an unlikely place. "One of the things that actually ended up clicking for me was I just looked at myself in the mirror," he said. "What does Derek like to do? Travel, cars, surfing, dogs, entrepreneurship, starting businesses. These are the things that interest me and somewhat define me. So go find those people."

That approach, starting with who the advisor actually is rather than who they think they should serve, is what separates a well-matched book from a scattered one. "Making sure that you have similar personality styles, shared interests, shared commonalities, real human connection data points," Notman said. "Try to find the best first date." Advisors who work with clients they genuinely connect with don't just convert at a higher rate. Those clients are easier to work with, take less time, and are far more likely to send referrals.

Notman spent years early in his career taking any client who would say yes. "I would work with anyone that can fog a mirror," he said. The cost of that approach compounds quickly. Clients who are a poor match take more time, generate less revenue, and almost never refer anyone. "Every moment you're spending with a client that's actually not driving revenue is a moment that you're losing money." The advisors who figure this out early and commit to it, even when it's uncomfortable to turn someone away, build practices that outgrow those who don't. "The bold ones that can say no to the wrong client fit will be the ones that are long-time successful," Notman said.

Client timing

Timing is the factor most advisors underestimate, and Notman has learned it the hard way. "I got a new client and then I didn't talk to him for a year or two for whatever reason," he said. "I follow up and I'm like, we should talk about this. And they're like, we already did that with another advisor six months ago. The timing was off."

Most major life events tend to follow patterns by age, which means advisors who understand those patterns can reach a client before the window opens rather than after it closes. Career changes, first homes, new children, business sales, inheritances, divorce, retirement. These things don't happen randomly. Notman encourages advisors to use that predictability to get ahead of the conversation: "People like you tend to have this event at this age. Here's some planning opportunities we can work on now while it's easy versus dealing with the after effects of not planning."

Even more specifically, estate planning carries some of the highest stakes when timing is missed. "We know what happens when someone dies and you didn't plan," Notman said. "It's a hot mess." Because estate planning depends so heavily on timing, Notman shared a straightforward example: "If my wife's pregnant and we're due in six months, I want to talk to you about life insurance and getting a will. That's important to me." An advisor who shows up with that conversation before the baby arrives isn't pitching. They're paying attention.

"We want to be there with those people before and during these life events, not after. After they happen, it's reactive," Notman said. Advisors who stay in regular contact with their book catch these windows. The ones who go quiet between annual reviews find out about them six months too late.

Building financial advisor-client trust

Notman's definition of trust comes from a belief he's held since before he ever worked in financial services, shaped by his anthropology background and time working with at-risk youth. People are wired to connect with like-minded people. Trust grows through that connection, and it cannot be rushed.

"The relationship is almost all of what our clients actually pay for," Notman said. "They actually want to know, am I going to be okay? And does my advisor actually know who I am and have my best interest at heart?" Advisors who can genuinely answer yes to both of those questions are having a different kind of conversation than those who can't.

Notman talks about the meaning behind the money, the emotional weight that sits underneath every major financial decision. "Having a new kid, retiring, having a death. These are real things that people get emotional about," he said. "If we can have empathy there and really help them through these things, they're going to want to actually introduce us and refer us." Advisors who show up for those moments, and treat every life event as a human experience before it's a planning opportunity, earn a kind of client loyalty that a cold outreach campaign never will.

Technology has a role in building that trust, but only as a vehicle. Notman's filter for any tool he considers is straightforward: "What tool helps me be a better human advisor? Which thing takes work off my plate and helps me connect with the clients I actually want to talk to." The tools that fail that test are the ones that use data to reach out to prospects as if a relationship already exists. "We want to use data to create better human connection, but let's not do it in a creepy way," he said. "If someone called me and said all those things, I would be so creeped out. I would either hang up or be like, this is just weird and I'm not going to do business with you just because I don't like the fact that you know all this about me without my permission." The prospect has to drive the bus. When they reach out on their own terms because something they found made them feel genuinely understood, the conversation that follows is a different one entirely.

Trust is built over time and through deliberate touchpoints, and the best advisors are engineering those touchpoints before a prospect even knows they need one. Notman describes a system that starts with presence. A LinkedIn profile written in first person, content that reflects who the advisor actually is rather than what products they sell, newsletters that lead with value and make no pitch. "Don't always talk about Roth conversions or rollovers," he said. "Talk about who you are as an individual, things you've learned, mistakes you've seen clients make. Things people actually want to read."

The goal of that presence is to stay close to the life stages where planning conversations become urgent. When all of it works, the prospect does the reaching out. "Eventually they're going to be like, that white paper was great, that webinar was great, I've been following you for a while, and this thing is about to happen in my life and I want to work with you," Notman said. "Because they've felt that human connection. They've gotten to know you." By the time that call comes in, the trust is already there.

Where people are receiving recommendations for financial advisors

The assumption that referrals and warm introductions are the dominant way prospects find advisors is changing faster than most advisors realize. A study by FCOM Partners and Absolute Engagement surveyed over a thousand high-net worth individuals and found that referral-driven leads are declining. "The consumer now is starting to shift to what they think is warm," Notman said. "Less of them are looking at wanting to do referrals. They're not going to their best friend, their neighbor, their attorney to ask for a referral or introduction as much as they used to. They're actually going online."

That shift changes where advisors need to show up. "The real sweet spot is if you can get warm inbound leads to actually contact you first," Notman said. "That's what's super valuable." Warm inbound means the prospect comes to the advisor. They found the content, attended a webinar, subscribed to a newsletter, or were introduced by someone they trust. By the time they reach out, some version of fit and trust is already in place.

Every dollar invested in building an organic presence is an investment in warm prospects who arrive ready to talk. A website, content, a LinkedIn profile, a webinar series. Every dollar spent on cold leads is buying a harder conversation with a lower probability of closing.

Notman isn't opposed to paid advertising, but his argument is that organic has to come first. "I love organic. It's the long road, but it does really exponentially help us grow," he said. "Get the fire going. Then you can pour some gas on it." Paid advertising amplifies organic content that is already working. Without that foundation, it produces expensive leads that keep the conversion problem alive rather than solving it.

What Google’s algorithm update means for financial advisors

A current concern Notman raised is the significant change in how Google ranks financial content, one that has already reshaped search results for advisors and will continue to do so.

For years, many advisors have relied on content produced by their broker-dealer, home office, or a third-party marketing vendor to build a client book. A blog post that goes live under one advisor's name, identical or nearly identical to content published by thousands of others on the same platform. Until recently, this approach generated reasonable search traffic.

"Top 10 pages fell out of the top 100 all of a sudden," Notman said. "Google's saying, well, wait a minute. 8,000 people have the same blog post. This thing isn't relevant. This thing isn't valuable. We're going to penalize that." Google is now actively rewarding content that is specific, personal, and genuinely useful to the person searching for it. AI search tools including ChatGPT, Claude, Copilot, and Gemini are applying the same standard when they surface recommendations. Generic content no longer signals expertise or authority.

"How personalized is your website, or how similar is it to 10,000 other advisors' websites?" Notman asked. "Are you making things unique to you? People do notice. Google is certainly noticing now and they're penalizing it." The advisors whose digital footprint is genuinely personal are the ones the current search environment is built to reward.

How to use an advisor CRM for a leads pipeline

If there is one tactical point Notman returned to more than any other, it's this. The most valuable pipeline most advisors have is already in their CRM.

Existing clients already trust their advisor. They're connected to people who might need the same help. Their lives are changing in ways that create new planning opportunities, and they're far more likely to respond to outreach than a cold prospect is. "It was a lot harder to go find brand new clients versus going to my existing book of business and really thoughtfully mining it," Notman said. "There's probably a lot more opportunity in your book than you realize. You've got people with planning opportunities. You've got people with assets that you probably didn't know they had."

Estate planning is one of the most common gaps hiding inside an existing book of business. Many clients have outdated documents, no trust funding strategy, or no plan at all.

Notman encourages advisors to start by finding clients who haven't been contacted in a year or more, think about what life events they might be approaching, and reach out personally with a message that reflects genuine knowledge of who they are. Not an automated email, something that is personable and thoughtful. For those hesitant to reach out after a long silence, Notman is direct. "There'd be clients I haven't talked to in a year and a half. I'm nervous to go talk to them," he said. "Just reach out. It doesn't hurt."

That conversation often opens more than it seems. Ask who else in their life might benefit from a conversation. A webinar, a white paper, a newsletter, a short tool that helps someone understand their financial situation better. Each touchpoint builds familiarity, familiarity builds trust, and trust converts at a rate a purchased list never will.

Tips for financial advisors prospecting clients

Calculate your actual conversion rate

Count how many inquiries came in across every marketing channel and how many became clients. "Just really get clear on that number," Notman said. "Was there a good ROI? Were you happy with it?"

Open the CRM and find everyone who hasn't been contacted in a year or more

For clients advisors haven't contacted in a while, Notman offers an honest approach to the first message. Be transparent. "I am so sorry, life has happened, would love to reconnect and see what's going on." A 15-minute virtual check-in is enough. Clients share what has changed, and those changes open planning conversations.

Audit the digital presence 

"How personalized is your website, or how similar is it to 10,000 other advisors' websites?" Notman asked. "How about your social media profile, your bio, the things you post? Are you using standard templates that you have not customized at all? People do notice. Google is certainly noticing now and they're penalizing it."

Watch the Estate Guru and Derek Notman webinar 

Derek Notman's full conversation with Estate Guru covers the behavioral data behind advisor-client matching, how predictive life event signals work in practice, and how Couplr AI is helping advisors reach the right people at the right time.

To play the video, hover over the image at the top of the page and click the play button when it appears.

‍

Our platform is attorney-led, which means we bring the attorney to you. Keep in mind: We are not a law firm and do not provide legal advice–that’s what our in-network attorneys are for. While we work to make sure our information services are accurate, they’re meant as resources. Our materials and services don’t substitute for the advice of an attorney.